What’s this ‘Liquidity’ that Everyone Keeps Blaming?
“Stocks are going up because there is so much liquidity.”
“Valuations are high and will remain high because there is a flood of liquidity.”
Liquidity is blamed for any and everything, usually. Bulls love it, bears blame it. But one thing is common. When you ask investors – “What is liquidity?” - what you get in return are empty stares, smiles, or at best, fund flows or traded volumes data.
Have you ever asked this question to yourself? What is liquidity and how to define it?
In a corridor conversation early in my career, I was often told that the flood of money brought forth by quantitative easing is going to lift the markets like never before. On other occasions, derivative traders mentioned the open interest rising with rising volumes and termed it ‘long buildup’ in a stocks. It was an indication that the ‘strong hands’ in the market liked this scrip.
One of the most familiar references to liquidity is usually the FII and DII flows. It is a common practice to state these as the primary, and for most investors, the only tool to measure ‘liquidity’ in the stock market.
This confused and perplexed me so much that I wrote a simple cheat sheet to tell myself what liquidity is. Here it is –
Liquidity, the most potent and important source of market moves, is of three primary types –
1. Market Liquidity
- Fund flows from foreign institutional investors, domestic institutions including mutual funds and trends in retail investments
- Total traded value of stocks
- Loan against shares’ book size and trends
- Options open interest and volume trends
- Traded volumes including delivery volumes
2. Interbank Liquidity
- Interbank liquidity refers to the surplus or deficit funds at any point that the banking system holds with the RBI, over and above statutory CRR requirements
- Durable liquidity
3. Credit availability and off-take
- Credit growth and the ability of the banking system to lend
- Money supply trends and their impact
The above triad structure presents a comprehensive way of looking at not only one part of liquidity impacting the markets but a complete picture of how liquidity manifests in financial markets and the economy.
Let’s look at each one of these in brief.
The large inflow of foreign institutional investors (FIIs), who bring in foreign portfolio investments (FPIs), have been regarded as one of the key determinants of market behaviour. India’s listed company total market capitalization is now nearly Rs 250 tn. Nearly half of this is held by promoters and the rest is ‘free-float’. FPIs hold nearly one-third of the free-float market capitalization. Their holdings are mostly consolidated in larger companies, and therefore, FPIs’ buying and selling of shares can have an outsized impact on stock prices.
Over the years, domestic institutions including mutual funds have seen their share of holding of stocks rise from nearly 10% to about 15% of the free-float now. Even small changes in shareholding from these institutions can cause large movements in stock prices, and are, therefore, a key monitorable for many traders and investors.
Daily FII and DII put together account for half the daily traded volumes on the cash market each day. Domestic mutual funds have become significantly large in terms of their total holding of Indian stocks. The consistent flows through SIPs and evolving trend in equity ‘Asset Under Management’ can help one to prepare for changes in the buying and selling pattern during volatile market phases.
Often, FPIs and DIIs behave differently by buying and selling alternatively. This creates powerful trends in the stock markets. It’s important to keep track these trends and gauge why they change.
The other part of market liquidity refers to the abundance of market orders and the depth at which the market is operating. This is usually a function of market sentiment and trending behaviour.
Long and stable uptrends attract lot of investors, and they keep bidding up the prices. It is said that bull markets feed off from consistent flows from the retail investors -knowing fully well that this is a virtuous feedback loop which evolves as the markets rise and it turns on itself when they correct. It is a sort of Frankenstein which bull markets develop, and it turns on itself when the trend changes.
Most investors face very poor market prices, wide bid-ask spreads and shallow volumes when prices fall precipitously. One rule of thumb which helps in avoiding mishaps has been that no major world equity index has ever hit a lower circuit while trading above its 50-day moving average.
In similar view, rising open interest with rising volumes allows stocks in futures and options segments to have faster moves as leverage positions favour these counters - knowing fully well, from one expiry series to the next, the kind of open interest changes happening helps in identifying the leader of a market.
The flavour of the above few can be set in an excel sheet with just a few rows and columns. When tracked daily, it helps in knowing how liquid is the market.
The second and most often quoted is the interbank liquidity. This became famous and continues to remain the top favourite of participants and media since the global financial crisis.
As of June 2021, the banking system had liabilities of Rs 164 tn (client demand and time deposits) and approximately Rs 16 tn in capital. This funds Rs 110 tn in loans and Rs 54 tn in reserve assets.
CRR and SLR constitutes the reserve assets. As per RBI’s guidelines, banks must maintain 4% of CRR and 18% of SLR of Net Demand and Time Liabilities (NDTL). So at about Rs 164 tn of NDTL, banks should maintain Rs 6.5 tn in CRR and Rs 29.5 tnin SLR (through HQLA).
On any given day, if the banking system holds surplus CRR balance over and above Rs 6.5 tn, this is a surplus and is given the name interbank liquidity surplus. Also if the banking system holds high quality liquid assets in SLR over and above the statutory amount, it adds to banking system liquidity. For instance, at this time, the banking system holds nearly Rs 16 tn in excess HQLA (High Quality Liquid Assets) over and above the statutory requirement of Rs 29.5 tn .
Of course, the above is a simplistic example of looking at interbank liquidity surplus. There are ways in which this liquidity changes everyday at the liquidity adjustment facility (LAF) window of the RBI. Here, banks can covert one form of surplus to the other to cover its deficit elsewhere, say from SLR to CRR. So, in effect, it maintains a total statutory level of CRR + SLR.
This is the interbank liquidity surplus which is talked about often as the key liquidity measure. RBI has maintained an interbank liquidity surplus for nearly five years now and this has resulted in easier financial conditions. However, this interbank liquidity can’t be lent out in the literal sense. When there is fresh demand for loans, and banks makes a loan, it creates another deposit in the borrower’s account. Thus, lending creates new money and this is the largest money multiplier.
What surplus interbank liquidity does is it keeps financial conditions easy, rates lower and outlook more visible for the near future. This allows banks to meet demand for credit, if it picks up with better visibility.
Credit availability and off-take
Let’s first look at the money supply. There are three key variables to understand
M1 - zero-yielding currency notes, coins and bank demand deposits
M2 – M1 and all the post office savings bank deposits
M3 – the broadest measures which includes M1 and all the times deposits with the banking system.
Central banks usually have policy tools such as changing short term interest rates like the repo rate, or changing the liquidity profile of the banking system by cutting the statutory ratios like the CRR and SLR. When a central bank wants to enact a counter cyclical policy to promote growth or fight deflation, it employs a number of measures. It cuts short term interest rates, increases liquidity surpluses in the system and supports the interbank market.
It can also achieve lower rates by raising the amount of money in circulation. Usually, central banks target M1 by raising currency in circulation, that is printing of more currency notes. However, the real impact on the economy is when the broader money (M3) moves higher. The biggest driver of broader money (to put it simply, about two-thirds or more) is contributed by changes in demand for loans which are a function of term deposits and demand deposits. It is a sort of chicken and egg.
When a bank lends, it creates a deposit in the borrower’s bank. The subsequent transactions create the flow of money and has a multiplier impact. More loans create more deposits which allows banks to lend more. In short, lending creates its own deposits.
The underlying fact is that the central banks can do little to create demand for loans. All it can do is create conducive conditions for borrowers to borrow. In short, Central Banks have little impact on M3 if it only uses its conventional monetary policy tools.
A growth in broad money supply is a reliable indicator of economic growth. The central banks, unable to move M3 much through conventional policy then rely on what is called the unconventional monetary policy or Quantitative Easing (QE). The central banks, through the secondary market, buys Government Securities and other high quality assets from financial participants, which are mostly banks. This causes the yields on those papers to fall as the central banks become the buyer of the last resort, and in some cases, the largest buyers in the market. The fall in yields and concomitant rise in bond prices causes balance sheets to improve and adds more heft to the conventional policy tools.
What it also does is create a search for yields. Because fixed income assets, or bonds, start giving lower returns. investors are likely to shift their allocation in favour of riskier asset classes like equities. This causes the balance sheet of the corporate sector to improve tremendously as their equity prices rise and they raise money cheaply. This creates a virtuous cycle which eventually revs up the economy through higher corporate and government spending. This is the most ideal cycle that central banks target but may need many more other factors to go right.
In essence, the quantitative easing cycle is a support function of conventional monetary policy. It works wonderfully in economic setups which have strong underlying potential growth.
Let’s see where we stand today:
- Many indicators of market liquidity are up since the pandemic. For example, the traded value at NSE averaged Rs 2.5 tn pre-pandemic shot up to Rs 10 tn in Mar-20 and remains afloat at Rs 13 tn a month. Futures are painting another rosy story with stock futures contracts at 2200K, a number that stood at 1400K in the 2017 bull market. Additionally, retail stock futures contracts is at a whopping 800K+! It is not just liquidity but also leverage. There has been some easing off in other forms of market liquidity. Loans against shares peaked at Rs 62 bn in Jul-20 and has now settled at Rs 44 bn. FII flows for FY21 were tall at US$ 36 bn but FY22 YTD stands at US$ 2.1 bn. Quite unequivocally, still many contours of market liquidity remain buoyant, the question is for how long?
- Interbank liquidity - A gift of RBI, rather! Interbank liquidity was in deficit for many years pre-demonetization and has been in surplus of some degree ever since. In the last months, it has broadly been range bound between Rs 5 tn to Rs 6.5 tn – a level at which RBI expresses its comfort, although recently it has surged to a record of Rs 10 tn. Many TLTROs and repos have contributed to this surge but most importantly, it is also the banks who are parking the surplus back with RBI instead of looking at credit disbursements. The overall SLR investments are at nearly Rs 46 tn, about Rs 16 tn over and above what’s needed statutorily. While the risk aversion by banks is a popular theory, credit demand has also suffered in the pandemic. Given that interbank liquidity is overnight liquidity, looking at durable liquidity is more pertinent, the growth of which has averaged at 6% in the past 12 months. The banking liquidity is not as strong as it optically appears- given that durable liquidity falls below the nominal GDP.
- Non-food credit has grown at 6% in the past year, though the silver lining is that long-term loans still grew at 12%. Banking credit is now only a part of India’s credit story, with ECBs/Corporate bonds/NBFCs/Fintech all contributing to the overall cycle. Historically, credit is the last indicator to recover post recessionary periods but is also the confirmatory signal for sustained recovery. Due to lack of credit, while M1 has grown close to 16%, M3 has only grown by 11% off-late. Total M3 in the system stands at Rs 193 tn, below the nominal GDP for the year.
The pandemic has taken India out of monetary repressions where most liquidity numbers have normalized. The flair of excess liquidity is visible only in the market liquidity. Structural liquidity has only filled the gaps but can’t be termed as “excess” thus far. After all, “excess” is relative!
The liquidity matrix at this time is flashing red at many places. The outstanding contracts in the futures and options markets is one such place. The extreme readings on interbank liquidity also mean that a reversal even to the surplus standards of the past can cause large volatile episodes in stocks. Be wary of deep gashes when the above mean revert.
Liquidity has many flavours and shapes. We need to track all of them to arrive at an understanding of what constitutes liquidity. So next time when some ones says that stocks are rising because of liquidity, know that there can be many ephemeral or structural factors at play.
At this time liquidity is surplus in most of its forms and is keeping most asset classes buoyant. But there are kinks in the armour because we are in a no man’s land and we do not know the path of return. Be prepared for big moves ahead as liquidity changes shapes and colours.
About the authorSahil Kapoor - Vice President & Head - Products & Market Strategist at DSP Investment Managers. In his own words, his writing is his "Gurudakshina" - his humble repayment to Mr. Market.
This note is for information purposes only. In this material DSP Investment Managers Pvt Ltd (the AMC) has used information that is publicly available and is believed to be from reliable sources. While utmost care has been exercised, the author or the AMC does not warrant the completeness or accuracy of the information and disclaims all liabilities, losses and damages arising out of the use of this information. Readers, before acting on any information herein should make their own investigation & seek appropriate professional advice. Any sector(s)/ stock(s)/ issuer(s) mentioned do not constitute any recommendation and the AMC may or may not have any future position in these. All opinions/ figures/ charts/ graphs are as on date of publishing (or as at mentioned date) and are subject to change without notice. Any logos used may be trademarks™ or registered® trademarks of their respective holders, our usage does not imply any affiliation with or endorsement by them.